Call Us Today 
Fault in a car accident is determined by what the evidence shows about how the crash happened. Investigators review what occurred on the road and how the drivers were moving just before the vehicles made contact.
They may also consider police notes, photos from the scene, witness statements, and insurance records as they piece together what happened. After a crash, deciding who is responsible is rarely simple, especially when insurers review statements and documents line by line.
Our Fort Myers car accident lawyer will help gather the right records, respond to those requests, and address how Florida handles fault when a crash involves injuries and losses.
What ‘Fault’ Means Under Florida Law
Fault means who is legally responsible for causing a crash. In Florida, fault can fall on more than one driver or another liable party. The state uses a comparative fault system under Florida Statutes § 768.81. It allows fault to be divided based on each person’s actions.
When fault is shared, each driver receives a percentage of responsibility. That percentage affects how much a person may recover.
For example, if a driver is found to be 20% at fault, their recovery is reduced by 20%. Florida law still allows a driver to pursue a claim when they share some fault. However, a person cannot recover damages if they are found to be more than 50% responsible for the crash.
Expect More, Receive More: Legal Support That Feels Like Family
How Police Crash Reports Affect Fault Decisions
Police officers usually arrive soon after a crash and write down what they observe. That report can shape an insurance company’s view of fault.
When a police officer fills out a report, they may record things like :
- What each driver said at the scene and whether those accounts match later statements.
- Check where witnesses were standing to determine what they saw or could see when the crash happened.
- Notes about the road and weather, including visibility, lighting, or surface conditions.
- Cite if any traffic laws were violated, such as speeding, failure to yield, or distracted driving.
Details like these get insurance adjusters’ attention. They can use these notes when they begin evaluating a claim. Courts can also consider them later, but a police report alone does not decide fault. Other records and evidence can carry just as much weight.
What Kinds of Evidence Show Who Caused a Crash?
Fault decisions rely on proof, not guesses. The goal is to see what happened and why.
Evidence often includes:
- Medical records
- Photos from the crash scene
- Vehicle damage
- Police notes
- Witness statements that help explain what drivers were doing just before the crash.
Insurance companies compare these records to look for consistency. When details line up, it is easier to assign fault. When they do not, disputes about what happened and who’s liable often follow.
Click To ContactHow Insurance Companies Decide Who’s At Fault in Accidents
Insurance companies run their reviews after a crash, and they do not rely on one document alone. Their decision affects who pays for damage and injuries. That decision does not always match what the drivers expect.
Adjusters can review various materials as they piece together what happened. They can look at police reports, photos, repair estimates, receipts, and other items. They can check traffic laws to see whether a driver may have violated a rule.
Take Care When Speaking With Adjusters
In some cases, they ask drivers for recorded statements, which you should be careful about. These calls often happen soon after the crash, before someone knows the status of their injuries. Early statements may later be compared to medical records, photos, or repair estimates.
Speaking with our Fort Myers personal injury lawyer at this stage can help you or your loved one understand what an insurer is asking you and how your answers could affect a fault decision. We can take over communication with the adjuster to guard against your answers being taken out of context.
Problems People Face When Proving Who Should Cover Damages
Proving fault is not always simple. Many crashes involve missing or unclear information.
Common problems include:
- Conflicting driver statements.
- Witnesses who leave before speaking with the police.
- Delays in medical treatment.
- Lack of photos or video.
Insurance companies can use these and other gaps to question a claim or reduce what they pay.
How Our Fort Myers Car Crash Lawyer Handles Fault
Trying to prove who’s liable for your damages can be challenging when you don’t feel well and have to rest and treat your injuries.
Dealing with an insurance company may only add to your stress. We can take this task off your hands and manage it for you. We will gather records and organize proof tied to fault.
This may mean:
- Reviewing police reports and photos during our analysis of what happened.
- Following up on any missing evidence that can support your claim.
- Preparing a case if we cannot agree to a settlement with the insurance company.
- This support helps keep fault decisions focused on facts instead of assumptions.
Deadlines for Filing Fault-Based Claims in Florida
In Florida, you generally have two years from the date of the crash to sue for damages under Florida Statutes § 95.11(5)(a). We encourage you not to wait too long if you want to pursue damages in court.
Letting the deadline expire without filing your case can lead to losing your right to seek financial recovery, even when fault is clear. When you connect with our team, we can tell you how much time you have left. We will keep your case on schedule and file it on time.
Viles & Beckman Will Determine Who’s At Fault in Your Accident
Viles & Beckman has served communities in Southwest Florida since 1995. With 40+ years of combined experience, our team treats every case with care and gives each client full attention. No case is too small for us. The goal is the same for us—that you get a five-star client experience from The 5–Star Law Firm™.
When we speak with you, we will review the evidence tied to fault in the crash and advise you on how we can help you. Our injury lawyers work on contingency—you pay nothing unless they win.
A Board Certified attorney is on staff, and our attorneys speak Spanish, Russian, and Creole, making help accessible to many families. You can start by calling us today for a free consultation.
